Our Three Determinations

EVERY FILE RECEIVES ONE OF THESE.

RESOLVED

The matter is closed. Something in the file — the elapsed time, the context, the framing, the simple act of writing it down and having someone read it — resolves the open question. Not always by answering it. Sometimes by changing what the question was.

71% of files receive this determination. We don't predict which ones. The ones that do tend to surprise the people who submitted them.

UNRESOLVABLE

Some things can't be resolved. The other party can't be reached. The information needed doesn't exist. The question is unanswerable by its nature. This is also an answer. An Unresolvable determination formally closes the file on the grounds that no resolution is possible — and that expecting one was the source of the problem.

28% of files. This determination is often the harder one to receive. It is also, frequently, the more useful one.

PENDING FURTHER EVIDENCE

Rare. We issue this when something specific is missing that, if found, would genuinely change the determination. We tell you what to look for. If you find it and resubmit, we re-review. We do not issue this determination to avoid making a harder call. We issue it when we mean it.

1% of files. We've issued this determination 12 times. 7 of those files were subsequently resubmitted with new evidence. 5 resolved. 2 became Unresolvable.

Determinations are final. We do not re-open closed files. We do not offer appeals. If new evidence emerges that is genuinely material, you may submit it as a new file. We will read it as such, without reference to the prior determination. You start with a clean record. That is also sometimes the point.